Best American Comics 2007 (collected from mid-2005 to mid-2006), edited by Chris Ware and Anne Elizabeth Moore:
Contents:
Jerry Moriarty. Dad Watches (Endpapers) from Kramer’s Ergot
ii : Ivan Brunetti. The Horror of Simply Being Alive from Schizo
* iv : Art Spiegelman. Portrait of the Artist As a Young %@#*! from Virginia Quarterly Review and The New Yorker
xii : Anne Elizabeth Moore. Foreword
xvi : Chris Ware. Introduction
* 1 : R. and Aline Crumb. Winta Wundaland from The New Yorker
4 : Sophie Crumb. “Hey, Soph, Whazzup?” from Mome
* 5 : Alison Bechdel. The Canary-Colored Caravan of Death from Fun Home
33 : C. Tyler. Just A Bad Seed and Once, We Ran from Late Bloomer
* 40 : Lynda Barry. Ernie Pook’s Comeek (Excerpt) from Ernie Pook
44 : Lauren Weinstein. Skate Date, Waiting, and John and I Go to the Movies from Girl Stories ix
49 : Vanessa Davis. Untitled Diary Strips from Kramer’s Ergot
* 53 : Gabrielle Bell. California Journal from Mome
65 : Ivan Brunetti. Six Things I Like About My Girlfriend from Schiz0
66 : Jeffrey Brown. These Things, These Things from Little Things
75 : Ron RegĂ© Jr. fuc 1997: We Share a Happy Secret, But Beware, Because the Modern World Emerges from Kramer’s Ergot
91 : John Porcellino. Country Roads—Brighton from King-Cat Comics and Stories
95 : Jonathan Bennett. Needles and Pins from Mome
* 106 : Kevin Huizenga. Glenn in Bed from Ganges
118 : David Heatley. Sambo from Mome
* 121 : Sammy Harkham. Lubavitch, Ukraine, 1876 from Kramer’s Ergot
* 132 : Miriam Katin. Untitled (The List) from We Are on Our Own
144 : Ben Katchor. Shoehorn Technique from Chicago Reader
* 156 : Adrian Tomine. Shortcomings (Excerpt) from Optic Nerve
175 : David Heatley. Cut Thru and Laundry Room from Mome
* 177 : Gilbert Hernandez. Fritz After Dark from Luba’s Comics and Stories
* 201 : Kim Deitch. No Midgets in Midgetville from The Stuff of Dreams
219 : Anders Nilsen. Dinner and a Walk from Big Questions #7: Dinner and a Nap
* 230 : Charles Burns. Black Hole (Excerpt) from Black Hole
240 : Gary Panter. Untitled (Discrete Operations Vehicle—Burning Gall) from Jimbo’s Inferno
251 : C.F. Blond Atchen and the Bumble Boys from The Ganzfeld
263 : Ivan Brunetti. My Bumbling, Corpulent Mass from Schizo
264 : Tim Hensley. Meet the Dropouts from Mome
267 : Paper Rad. Kramer’s Ergot from Kramer’s Ergot
280 : David Heatley. Walnut Creek from Mome
* 285 : Dan Zettwoch. Won’t Be Licked! The Great ’37 Flood in Louisville from Drawn & Quarterly Showcase
315 Contributors’ Notes
326 100 Distinguished Comics from August 31, 2005 to September 1, 2006
Endpages Seth, Wimbledon Green
Chris Ware (
Jimmy Corrigan, Acme Comics Novelty Library) may need to be kept away from the editing desk. He's a brilliant writer/artist, but his writerly tendency towards tales of woe pretty much informs this entire collection. So too does an overemphasis on autobiographical comics -- and autobiographical comics dominate the Indy comix scene in much the same way that superheroes dominate the mainstream. Fine, non-autobiographical stories by Kim Deitch and Gilbert Hernandez surface towards the middle of this collection like welcome oasises of comedy and sorrow.
There's other good work here, though I'm not a fan of excerpting longer works to shoehorn them into a collection like this. There's also some truly godawful experimental comics work included, Kramer's Ergot being the worst offender -- it's like a Victor Moscoso piece as translated by an unartistic child. I'd forgotten that Gary Panter had disappeared for awhile. The piece here reminds me why this was a good thing. I've starred the stuff I liked. For the most part, the best pieces avoid the obsessive and often humourless navel-gazing of a lot of autobiographical comics, through talent or subject matter or both.
Lightly recommended.